I have to say C, though I can understand why you might want to go with A (it looks faster). I think i will accept, without missing terribly the others, whichever you do use, so long as it is completely consistent. you could probably make everything with your left hand, but as long as it was consistent, I could put it down to artistic choice.
I knew people tend to choose B,C over A bc of the 3-D which looks more well-drawn, but A retain more of the classic 2D anime-style, which is also pretty good.
I cant put a finger on which one they are all good, except for the stone slime.. it has to B, bc only B has texture that is not smooth and shiny for a stone, the stone slime has to be rough and has irregular surface, the others are not like that and they are not natural.
Here are my thoughts: I’t highly depends on the whole content of the game-
A If you use brighter colors, want the game to have a bit of a happier mood and wan’t it to look more simplistic.
B if you want the enemies to look a little bit darker compared to the background and want them to look more detailed than simplistic.
C If you want the enemies to look a little bit darker compared to the background and want to keep a firm middle between simplistic and detailed artstyle.
You may not find this very useful, but you may take notes on some of the things I mentioned. Keep up the good work :stars: :stars: :stars:
I prefer ‘C’ since the shading is quite detailed and pleasing for the eye – also, compared to ‘B’, the highlights are more smooth and do not clash with the outlining :smirk:
I prefer B because the shadows are more saturated and that gives more depth to the foe. In my opinion A has too little saturation and C has too much saturation, so that’s why I prefer B.
id say either C or B though i prefer B some of the slime being a bit embossed gives it a more 3D kinda perspective i think although its not very noticeable unless you just stare at it long enough :yay:
perfer C :love2:
BbbbbbbbbbbbBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB :stars:
I like it lighter so I say A.
C version in my opinion. feels more natural to me :yay:
Somewhere in the middle of A and B
I would say B, intermediate between too much polish and unpolished :yay:
I like C because B has too many shadows and A is too bright
C to annoy you with extra work.
But seriously, it looks like the best. Probably closest to the older games’ style.
B, It pops out more
I have to say C, though I can understand why you might want to go with A (it looks faster). I think i will accept, without missing terribly the others, whichever you do use, so long as it is completely consistent. you could probably make everything with your left hand, but as long as it was consistent, I could put it down to artistic choice.
I WON’T B ❗ ❗ ❗
I think I like B the most
i prefer A because the shading at B is too strong and the shading at C is too light 😐
Either A or C. Not B.
THIS ARTICLE NOW HAS THE MOST COMMENTES
I knew people tend to choose B,C over A bc of the 3-D which looks more well-drawn, but A retain more of the classic 2D anime-style, which is also pretty good.
I cant put a finger on which one they are all good, except for the stone slime.. it has to B, bc only B has texture that is not smooth and shiny for a stone, the stone slime has to be rough and has irregular surface, the others are not like that and they are not natural.
i think i like more C
Here are my thoughts: I’t highly depends on the whole content of the game-
A If you use brighter colors, want the game to have a bit of a happier mood and wan’t it to look more simplistic.
B if you want the enemies to look a little bit darker compared to the background and want them to look more detailed than simplistic.
C If you want the enemies to look a little bit darker compared to the background and want to keep a firm middle between simplistic and detailed artstyle.
You may not find this very useful, but you may take notes on some of the things I mentioned. Keep up the good work :stars: :stars: :stars:
I will definitly prefere C style !
B ❗
I prefer ‘C’ since the shading is quite detailed and pleasing for the eye – also, compared to ‘B’, the highlights are more smooth and do not clash with the outlining :smirk:
I totally agree with you
Matt, I have no gosh diddly darn idea what the difference is. :scared:
I really like C’s style! The different shades of colors makes the enemies look more… alive. idk hard to explain, but i did like it more. 🙂
I’d go with C
I think C because B looks a little out of place on enemies that aren’t lava slimes.
I know you already made your decision, but in case you still care :tongue: I like C the most! :hurray:
B has the highest level of detail so that one is my favorite. A is a bit to simplistic for my liking but C would also be fine. :smirk:
Can’t go wrong with B.
B or C :smirk:
B, it has more colors and details. IMO it looks better.
i can bearly tell the difference but i would go with b
I say C it makes it look like the lava slime is glowing but they are all good
I vote C.
You’re free to use whatever style of shading you like.
I prefer A, but I like C too. B’s shading seem too much.
i prefer b, but personally i barely noticed a difference untill 5 minutes after staring at smiles
B
I prefer B because the shadows are more saturated and that gives more depth to the foe. In my opinion A has too little saturation and C has too much saturation, so that’s why I prefer B.
I prefer C, but B is fine :yay:
B
:smirk: :smirk: :smirk: :smirk: :smirk: :smirk: :smirk: :smirk: :smirk:
B :love2:
B, because it looks like there are pebbles on the slimes.
If those are supposed to be just highlights, then C because it has more depth than A.
B definitely, they underlining shadows make the little details pop out more.
I think simple A is fine
B actually looks like thoose light-blobs are protruding out of the slimes
B kind of bothers me. The slimes just don’t look right to me…
C is my favorite, but A is also good.
I think exactly the same thing that this guy.
I prefer B because it has a bit more shading than A but doesn’t have too much :bacon:
I agree
i prefer C the most, :hurray:
I would say B because
C look’s like it’s lacquered and to shiny for the eyes
A look’s a bit unpolished
so B and BTW great work :yay:
I can barely see any difference, but I like B the most.
C looks right to me.
id say either C or B though i prefer B some of the slime being a bit embossed gives it a more 3D kinda perspective i think although its not very noticeable unless you just stare at it long enough :yay:
B
P.S: Hey, how much have you done on EBF5???
I’m dying to know.
I think I would prefer C. :smirk: